Who is Better Fit to Earn a Ticket to October: The Houston Astros or Minnesota Twins?

In today’s era of big-money spending baseball where clubs practically buy their way to the postseason, it’s refreshing to see two thrifty clubs in the heat of the summer race for October, leading their divisions despite being in the lower half of total 2015 roster salaries.  Who at the beginning of the year would have guessed that right now (over 1/3 the way into the season) the Minnesota Twins and Houston Astros are leading the chase for the playoffs in the American League?  But like so many spring flings, most such clubs will often fade down the stretch, limited by lack of depth and star power.  Which of these teams is better equipped to sustain their surprising start, the Astros or Twins?

Not surprisingly, both clubs are built quite similar.  They encompass teams full of bright young stars that are both highly touted and talented, and are quite affordable at the same time.  However, a few key high priced veterans bring experience and key plays to ensure that the club has a fighting chance.  Every once in a blue moon, the cogs are put together for a contending season.  This time appears to be now for both these teams.

The Astros seem to be the more impressive story, given that their payroll is good for second lowest in the Majors.  The emerging hero is Dallas Keuchel, a 3^rd year player who has made the transition from average arm to dominating starter.  His 1.85 ERA is 4^th in the big leagues among regular starters.  Offensively, guys like Jose Altuve and Jake Marisnick look to have bright futures too.  Veterans like Luis Valbuena do their part as well.  However, the bullpen is where the team shines.  Pat Nesheck, Will Harris, and Tony Sipp are providing late-inning support, and it’s paying off.  A nice X-factor for the club is the great start to 21-year-old pitcher Lance McCullers’ career.  His 4 starts have him perched with a 1.88 ERA and 2 wins.

The Twins roster salary is 18^th in baseball and reflects a team with more name recognition and experience.  Solid offensive output comes from Torii Hunter and Joe Mauer.  Meanwhile, a core of hitters coming to fruition include Kurt Suzuki, Brian Dozier, and Trevor Plouffe.  Youngster Eduardo Escobar is also making an impact.  But once again, pitching is key.  Led by a resurgent year by veteran Mike Pelfrey, Minnesota has a prized new asset in Kyle Gibson.  A rich bullpen featuring Blaine Boyer, Ryan Pressly, and J.R. Graham also includes a sensational closer in Glen Perkins, whose 1.67 has gotten him 21 saves, the leading figure in the MLB.

So who of these two clubs figures to continue their success?  I give Houston the edge, given that their division features more perennial chokers like the Texas Rangers and Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim.  The Twins’ AL Central looks a bit tighter given the inclusion of the free-spending Detroit Tigers and last year’s AL Champion darling Kansas City Royals.  Nevertheless, both teams could be included in the race down to the wire, and could certainly find themselves snagging a wild card spot and postseason entry.  With their solid bullpens and a couple great starters, each team has the right kind of roster built for lasting success.  However it plays out, these two clubs are enjoying wonderful seasons and should be among the more entertaining stories of the young 2015 MLB season.

Joe Mauer Autographed Helmet